iPad Pro M4 vs Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra
We analyzed 4,320 real reviews across Amazon (1,730), Reddit (1,120), YouTube (890), and TikTok Shop (580). The best hardware in the category vs. the tablet that actually replaces a laptop — the verdict depends entirely on what you need it to do.
The 30-Second Verdict
iPad Pro M4 is the better creative machine — chip performance, display quality, Apple Pencil Pro, and the deepest pro-app library on any tablet. Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra is the better productivity machine — a bigger screen, Samsung DeX for real multi-window work, a bundled S Pen, and a lower true cost once accessories are factored in. This is a genuine 5-5 tie: the “right” answer depends on whether you're buying a canvas for creative work or a screen for getting desktop-style work done.
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Chip Performance
iPad Pro WinsM4 — desktop-class, best-in-class single-core
Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 — very fast, still Android-capped
The M4 chip in the iPad Pro benchmarks closer to a MacBook than any tablet chip Samsung ships. Multi-core and GPU-bound tasks (4K video export, Stable Diffusion-style on-device AI, Final Cut Pro) run noticeably faster on the iPad. The Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 is still excellent — it handles multitasking, Samsung DeX, and gaming without breaking a sweat — but reviewers consistently note the ceiling is lower for pro creative work. For everyday use (browsing, video, note-taking) the gap is invisible.
Display Quality
iPad Pro Wins11"/13" tandem OLED, 1600 nits peak, ProMotion 120Hz
14.6" Super AMOLED, 120Hz, larger canvas
The iPad Pro's tandem OLED panel (introduced with M4) delivers true blacks, higher peak brightness, and best-in-class color accuracy — reviewers call it the best screen ever shipped on a tablet. The Tab S9 Ultra counters with sheer size: 14.6 inches of AMOLED real estate that makes split-screen multitasking and note-taking feel like a full canvas. Artists and PDF/note-takers often prefer the Tab's size; video and photo editors prefer the iPad's color fidelity and brightness.
Screen Size / Multitasking
Galaxy Tab Wins11" or 13" — great, but capped by iPadOS windowing
14.6" + DeX — true desktop-style multi-window
Samsung DeX transforms the Tab S9 Ultra into something close to a real desktop: resizable floating windows, a taskbar, and drag-and-drop between apps that behaves like Windows or macOS. iPadOS improved multitasking (Stage Manager) but reviewers still describe it as "multitasking with permission," citing inconsistent window resizing and app support gaps. For anyone treating the tablet as a laptop replacement, DeX + the larger screen is a genuine productivity advantage.
Stylus Experience
iPad Pro WinsApple Pencil Pro — squeeze gesture, haptics, barrel roll
S Pen (bundled free) — low latency, Samsung Notes integration
Apple Pencil Pro adds haptic feedback, a squeeze gesture for tool switching, and barrel roll for shading — refinements serious digital artists praise heavily in Procreate reviews. Its one drawback: it's a $129 add-on. Samsung includes the S Pen in the box on every Tab S9 Ultra, and its latency is excellent for note-taking and sketching in Samsung Notes. For artists chasing the best drawing tool money can buy, Apple Pencil Pro wins; for anyone who just wants a capable stylus included at no extra cost, the S Pen is the more practical value.
Software Ecosystem
iPad Pro WinsiPadOS + Mac Catalyst — deepest pro-app library
Android + tablet-optimized subset, improving
Final Cut Pro, Logic Pro, Procreate, and a massive library of tablet-optimized pro apps make the iPad the default choice for creative professionals. Android's tablet app situation has improved substantially since Google's 2023-2024 push, but reviewers still find stretched phone-UI apps more often than on iPad, especially outside Samsung's own app suite. This is the single most-cited reason creative professionals choose iPad over Tab S9 Ultra despite the hardware being competitive.
Battery Life
Galaxy Tab Wins~10 hours mixed use, efficient M4
~11-12 hours, larger 11,200 mAh battery
Both tablets comfortably last a full workday of mixed use. The Tab S9 Ultra's larger chassis houses a bigger battery (11,200 mAh vs. the iPad Pro's smaller cell), giving it a slight edge in longevity — roughly an extra hour in most reviewer benchmarks. Neither is a pain point; this category is close enough that most buyers won't notice a practical difference in daily use.
Build Quality / Design
iPad Pro Wins5.1mm thin, aluminum unibody, industry-leading
Armor Aluminum frame, IP68, still very premium
The M4 iPad Pro is the thinnest Apple product ever made at 5.1mm, and reviewers universally praise the fit and finish. The Tab S9 Ultra counters with IP68 water/dust resistance — a meaningful practical advantage the iPad Pro lacks entirely. Both feel like flagship hardware; Samsung wins on durability certification, Apple wins on sheer industrial design and thinness.
Camera System
Galaxy Tab Wins12MP wide + LiDAR, strong for scanning/AR
Triple camera (13MP+8MP UW+10MP tele), most versatile
Neither tablet is primarily a camera device, but the Tab S9 Ultra's triple-camera system (including a telephoto lens no iPad offers) gives it more framing flexibility for document scanning and video calls. The iPad Pro's LiDAR scanner is a differentiator for AR apps, room scanning, and measurement tools that Samsung doesn't match. Real-world use: most buyers use the front camera for video calls, where both perform similarly well.
Accessory Ecosystem
Galaxy Tab WinsMagic Keyboard, Pencil Pro — expensive, best-in-class
Book Cover Keyboard, S Pen included — better value
Apple's Magic Keyboard (with trackpad, floating design, and backlit keys) is widely considered the best tablet keyboard case available — at a steep $299-349 price. Samsung's Book Cover Keyboard is less refined but costs less, and critically, the S Pen ships in the box rather than as a $129 add-on. When reviewers total the real-world cost of a "fully equipped" tablet, the Tab S9 Ultra comes out meaningfully cheaper for a comparable feature set.
Price / Value
Galaxy Tab Wins$999+ base, $1,598+ realistic with accessories
$1,199 base includes S Pen, cheaper fully equipped
The iPad Pro starts at $999 (11") but the "real" price after adding Apple Pencil Pro and Magic Keyboard routinely exceeds $1,500-1,600. The Tab S9 Ultra starts higher at $1,199 but includes the S Pen, and Samsung's aggressive trade-in and bundle promotions frequently bring the effective price below a comparably equipped iPad. Reviewers and Reddit threads consistently flag Apple's accessory pricing as the biggest value complaint against an otherwise excellent product.
What Each Platform Reveals
Amazon
1,730 reviewsAmazon reviews for the iPad Pro skew toward students and creative hobbyists upgrading from an older iPad — most cite the display and Apple Pencil Pro as the deciding factor. Tab S9 Ultra Amazon reviews skew toward power users switching from a laptop, repeatedly praising DeX and the screen size for spreadsheet and multi-app work. Both products maintain 4+ star averages, but the negative reviews are telling: iPad Pro 1-star reviews cite accessory cost, Tab S9 Ultra 1-star reviews cite Android tablet app gaps.
r/iPad and r/GalaxyTab are predictably tribal, but r/ProductivityApps and r/artificial threads comparing the two are more useful. The consensus that emerges: digital artists and video editors lean iPad Pro for app quality and Pencil Pro; anyone who wants "a laptop replacement without a laptop OS" leans Tab S9 Ultra for DeX. A recurring Reddit thread title is literally "iPad Pro vs Tab S9 Ultra for [specific use case]" — the answer changes completely depending on the use case named.
YouTube
890 reviewsTech YouTubers universally acknowledge the iPad Pro's M4 chip and OLED display as best-in-class hardware, but a growing number of "power user" and productivity-focused channels now recommend the Tab S9 Ultra specifically for DeX-based workflows, citing that iPadOS still "handcuffs" the M4's potential. Side-by-side speed tests show the iPad winning raw benchmarks; side-by-side "day in the life" productivity videos show the Tab S9 Ultra completing more real desktop-style tasks without a companion laptop.
TikTok Shop
580 reviewsiPad Pro dominates TikTok content — Apple Pencil Pro art demos, aesthetic unboxings, and note-taking setups generate far more engagement than Tab S9 Ultra content. This creates a visibility gap: casual buyers who discover tablets through TikTok see the iPad almost exclusively, even though the Tab S9 Ultra scores competitively (or better) for the specific multitasking use cases many of those same buyers eventually care about once they own the device.
Top Complaints
iPad Pro M4
Apple Pencil Pro + Magic Keyboard add $400+ to real cost
iPadOS still limits true multitasking vs. macOS
M4 power is wasted without pro-level use cases
No file system parity with a real computer
USB-C accessory ecosystem inconsistent across models
Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra
Android tablet apps still stretched or unoptimized
DeX has occasional app compatibility quirks
Large 14.6" size is unwieldy for one-handed use
Resale value drops faster than iPad Pro
One UI tablet software updates lag behind phones
The Product Opportunity Gap
What 4,320 Reviewers Want
M4-class performance + Samsung DeX-style true multi-window desktop mode + a bundled stylus at a single fair price. Neither tablet delivers all three. The closest attempt is Apple's own Stage Manager improvements, but reviewers say it still isn't a real desktop windowing system. The clearest gap: buyers want the iPad's chip and display married to the Tab's DeX productivity model and included accessories — without paying twice for the privilege.
The Bottom Line
Buy the iPad Pro M4 if:
- • You do serious creative work (Procreate, Final Cut, Logic Pro)
- • You want the best display and Apple Pencil experience available
- • You're already invested in the Apple ecosystem
- • Raw chip performance matters more than screen real estate
Buy the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra if:
- • You want a laptop-replacement productivity experience (DeX)
- • You want the S Pen and a bigger canvas included in the box
- • You're in the Android/Samsung ecosystem already
- • You want the better fully-equipped price and IP68 durability
Compare Any Two Products
Run your own cross-platform review analysis in 30 seconds.